Local Cheese
Our superior collection of local cheeses are produced by small Amish farms and local Holmes county cheese makers.  These fresh and flavorful cheeses are full of local goodness and offer a wide array of specialty varieties.  Try a slice off our beautifully waxed wheels of Horseradish bacon cheddar or order a wedge of our six year aged yellow cheddar!

Local Cheese

Sort by:
10 Year Aged Cheddar Cheese
10 Year Aged Cheddar Cheese

Local

From $ 5.95
4 In One Cheese
4 In One Cheese

Local

From $ 4.95
Bacon Grilling Cheese
Bacon Grilling Cheese

Local

$ 7.95
Bacon Smoked Gouda Cheese
Bacon Smoked Gouda Cheese

Local

From $ 5.95
Beer Cheese
Beer Cheese

Local

$ 5.50
Black Diamond Cheddar Cheese
Black Diamond Cheddar Cheese

Local

From $ 11.95
Blazin' Mango Cheddar Cheese
Blazin' Mango Cheddar Cheese

Local

From $ 6.95
BRANCH Cheddar Cheese
BRANCH Cheddar Cheese

Local

From $ 5.95
Canadian Cheddar
Canadian Cheddar

Local

From $ 6.95
Cayenne Cheddar
Cayenne Cheddar

Local

$ 6.95